The aftermath of thanks: More of the same

Several years ago, I read a pair of dueling editorial in the New York Times, one of which lambasted the conventional wisdom of resolution-making to usher in the New Year. The article’s main point was that there is a tried and true link between our overblown best-intentions, our inevitable expectations of ourselves and the ensuing disappointment (in many cases out-and-out depression). Why aren’t we more than we are? Why can’t we do what we set out to do, be who we set out to be?


The writer went on to propose that the wiser use of that time would be to take stock and give thanks. Apparently, there is ample evidence that people who tend to count their blessings, also tend to feel, well, that they have something to count! Consciously taking into consideration what goodness resides in your life, amplifies your awareness of it, thus making you, in a word, happier.

In other much simpler words which I’ve just heard in David Steindl-Rast‘s TED talk, “Being happy doesn’t make you grateful. Being grateful makes you happy.” Yes! That’s the way to put it best.


So. Thanksgiving. Giving thanks. I try to do this routinely. As middle age has crept up on me, I’ve noticed that the stuff that keeps one up at night and without breath during the day seems to multiply and intensify at an alarming rate. Walking helps. Cutting down on caffeine helps. Wine, in the right doses, helps (Wrong doses? The opposite.) Physical contact—wordless expressions of love—help.

But stopping and being glad for the good stuff really, really helps.

Recently, I’ve actually managed to send myself back to sleep by silently droning through the list of things that DON’T need to be worried about. “I am grateful that there is plenty of food in the refrigerator…I am grateful that right this minute, no one I know and love is in the hospital…I am grateful that the elderly in my family are safe and loved…I am grateful that my children don’t call me by my first name…I am grateful that I survived my ownership of a 1964 Corvair convertible (unsafe at any speed) from the ages of 25-30.



People often ask me if, living in Italy, I celebrate Thanksgiving. My Cancerian answer is yes and no. Some years I do, and some years I don’t. I’m an idealist about these things, and it’s not a tradition that I want to experience wholly or partially lost in translation. My children only sort of get it, though my husband totally appreciates it. It’s the one American holiday that approximates almost all of the Italian ones: It’s about family. It’s about savoring good food and good company. It’s about living, rooted, in the season’s bounty. It’s about sacrificing hours in the kitchen because you want to nourish other people. And then it’s about sitting around together and being grateful for all of the above.

Sometimes, some years, we ritualize that. And some years we don’t. This year I did my best. Carrot soup (the requisite orange thing), roasted turkey, sausage apple and sage dressing, gravy, brussels sprouts, green beans, and apple pie. it was eaten with gusto and appreciation. The flavors are long gone, but I’m trying to keep the Thanks-giving part of that one day a daily affair.


Tomorrow is Christmas. And here I sit quietly filing through some recent experiences that brought ridiculous, non-proportionate happiness. Some of them are scattered randomly throughout this post. A purple cauliflower that turned turquoise during cooking, but ended up a dusty rose color, mixed with anchovies, garlic and pasta. A frost-bitten field of unpruned hydrangeas. (The first cold of  the year felt pure and clean. We needed it.)

An endless, experimental oyster dinner with my love, for which there was a different Italian wine for every non-Italian, cold-water course. Oysters, in all their slimy and briny glory, from many French estuaries, but also from Ireland and the Netherlands. My first “polenta pasticciata,” a heady mixture of polenta and gorgonzola, baked in the oven and served alongside roasted vegetables to appreciative silence on a cold day.


Garments—so naturally and beautifully formed—left casually modeled by two headless mannequins on a sidewalk in Como. And that dear dear city itself, which I look forward to visiting again, with its jewel of a lake, hidden between mountains, and its human-sized walled city which encloses one in a dignified embrace. And two book covers in a single display of Como’s Ubik bookstore that seemed to capture the essence of life: finding balance and stillness, staying on one’s toes, and trying (trying) to strike an insouciant, “I meant to do that” pose.

May you all, whoever and wherever you are, have a holiday full of good memories, health, sustaining thoughts and dreams, and loveliness in the extraordinary and banal details of your every-day loves and lives.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to The aftermath of thanks: More of the same

  1. M McKinley says:

    Dear Charlotte,

    Merry, happy Christmas to you and the whole family.

    I loved every word of this post and can completely relate to its sentiments. After my 20 years of living abroad and only occasionally trying (and failing) to recreate those perfect American holidays, I decided to move back to the US, in some small part so that I could have the big family meals and pick up all the traditions we had shared. But, as I probably should have known but didn’t, traditions evolve and are created anew as each family member changes or the family itself changes, grows or is diminished one way or another. The distances – physical, spiritual, philosophical, etc. – are just too great but we do our best.

    But, above and beyond all that, my daily exposure to and interaction with the homeless people who live in great numbers in the park across the street have quadrupled my sense of gratitude for every single thing I have, every experience I’ve enjoyed, my good health, my happy family. In the US, it could happen to anyone. Anyone.

    Tomorrow after I sing at the 10 a.m. service, I’ll fly to Oakland to be with my daughter Kate for a week. We fit in many of the traditions and we’ll add some new ones and be grateful.

    Blessings on your house!


  2. Merry Christmas from Canada!
    I enjoyed your thoughtful and lovely post.

  3. dayphoto says:

    I ADORED this post! You are so right…the glory of thankfulness really does help. And as you well know, having my last child able to function as normal, back to teaching, speaking correctly and processing information is the thing I am most grateful for this year.

    And…I thank you for helping me through all of the above!

    Merry Christmas in your lovely home in France or if not there in Milan!!!

    ¸.•*¨*•♪♫♫♪Merry Christmas ♪♫•*¨*•.¸¸♥

  4. Debra Kolkka says:

    Merry Christmas from snowy Lapland. Have a great day and a wonderful new year.

  5. PEIROUX says:

    Merry Christmas from Accolay !!

  6. Janette Gross says:

    Merry Christmas from sunny Santa Cruz, California! Your post was a lovely gift – thank you!

  7. Enjoy that sun! I always think a sunny Christmas must be very strange indeed, but we could use a ray or two about now. Have a great holiday Janette.

  8. ron says:

    thank you for sharing! (that’s what we learned at school today…and every day.) love the variety of images. glad that happiness can come from so many different places. i’m going to guess that that’s probably healthier in many ways. carry on!

  9. What a gorgeous post – so very thoughtful. Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s